Hilarie's brother Johnny Jackson told the Post that Hilarie had only been on the dating site about two months, as that was when he had broken up with his last girlfriend. Despite the abuse, her mother remained at the house with her father even long after she . Bustos, Ellington and Gray were also charged with violation of probation. The Orlando Sentinel/Auburndale Police Department. But Ellington also acknowledged he was seeking a better deal from the State Attorney, he said, and he questioned his credibility as well. It was a setup, police say. Cruz and his family are now planning a funeral while trying to come to terms with the loss. FP Trending February 24, 2023 16:10:44 IST. Do The foursome arrived at the victims apartment Friday evening and carried out the robbery, which ended with the 27-year-old getting shot, police said. Norgard responded that prosecutors could reduce the charges against Bustos to lesser offenses if her testimony results in Warner's conviction. The three men and Ms Bustos were later arrested and charged with conspiracy to commit robbery, robbery with a firearm and first-degree murder. Acting as a sister show to both Chicago Fire and Chicago Med, Chicago P.D. 15-Year-Old Georgia Girl Is Apparently Shot in Head While in Bed, 3 Suspects Arrested, Fla. Business Owner Who Claimed Self-Defense After Allegedly Shooting Man Urinating on Building Is Charged, Ga. Police Officer Arrested After Naked Body of Missing 16-Year-Old Girl Found in Woods, Man Accused of Luring 15-Year-Old Girl from Dallas Mavericks Game Charged with Sexual Assault, Ga. Woman Was Killed Inside Car Dealership, Suspect Is Business Partner She Used to Date, Texas Man Accused of Murdering Girlfriend Who Planned to Confront Him About Being Married, Texas Man Allegedly Broke into Estranged Wife's Home Wearing a Ski Mask, Killed Her While Daughter Escaped, How a True Crime Podcast Freed 2 Georgia Men Wrongfully Imprisoned 25 Years on Murder Conviction, Suspect Arrested in Stabbing Death of Georgia Grandmother Who Allegedly Interrupted Him Stealing Car, Suspect Who Wanted Child Allegedly Lured Pregnant Ark. The victim's brother, Angel Cruz, said that Adam brought out the good in everyone. Arrest of four people in connection with the killing including 18-year-old Hailey Bustos, who went on the date with him, Andre Warner, 26, Gary Gray, 31, and Joshua Ellington . Viewers wondered if this was the moment when Hank would return to a dark place. Bustos told the jury a mutual friend, Evelyn Belmont, had helped her set up her PlentyofFish account a couple weeks earlier. By Lauren Parks. The victim met Hailey Bustos through a dating website, then went on a date with her on Aug. 19, 2016. A GoFundMe set up by a close friend of Hilarie is raising money for his daughter and funeral services, as Hilarie did not have life insurance. 2023, Charter Communications, all rights reserved. Hilaries brother Johnny Jackson told the Post that Hilarie had only been on the dating site about two months, as that was when he had broken up with his last girlfriend. All Rights Reserved. All four are charged with felony murder and aggravated assault and remain in custody, according to jail records. Mar 3, 2022 . It's unclear if Hilarie's 5-year-old daughter Lajaya was in the apartment at the time of the robbery and shooting. Freaking! At the . Hilarie and Bustos reportedly had a great first date; the pair went bowling and then back to his apartment where she met his roommate. One co-defendant, Hailey Bustos, 21, testified for more than three hours Thursday. Adam was a good man. Christina Bustos replied by telling the friend to leave her alone and let the f***ing courts do there [sic] job. She added that she never claimed her daughter did not deserve to be punished, but noted that she, too, lost a child. At times Bustos acknowledged she did want a better deal, but then she also shot back at Norgard, That's not why I'm here for, when he pressed the issue. Posted on August 22, 2016 by konniemoments in Crime // 0 Comments. Ducharme said the victim, the father of a 5 . text: 'Report this ad', According to the Sentinel, Bustos showed up at his apartment as planned the next evening, but she brought three men with her. 2023 FOX Television Stations, from SUN 4:00 PM CST until MON 3:00 PM CST, Douglas County, Kanabec County, Mille Lacs County, Morrison County, Todd County, from SUN 6:00 PM CST until MON 3:00 PM CST, Crow Wing County, East Becker County, East Otter Tail County, Grant County, Hubbard County, Mahnomen County, North Cass County, Northern Aitkin County, South Aitkin County, South Cass County, South Clearwater County, Wadena County, West Becker County, West Otter Tail County, from SUN 9:00 AM CST until MON 12:00 PM CST, Clay County, Norman County, Wilkin County, from SUN 6:00 PM CST until MON 6:00 PM CST, Carlton/South St. Louis Counties, Pine County, Southern Lake/North Shore, Burnett County, Douglas County, Washburn County, Gov. "She never stopped saying he was the shooter.". Just one night after they went on their . Hilaire was shot execution-style by a cohort of Bustos who was previously convicted and sentenced. Hilarie was an Auburndale native and an aspiring boxer. Police said Hilarie and Bustos met through . Adam Hilarie, 27, was shot in the head during a robbery that police say Hailey Bustos, 18, arranged within hours after visiting his home on their first date in the central Florida town of Auburndale. Hilarie and Bustos reportedly had a great first date; the pair went bowling and then back to his apartment where she met his roommate. text: 'Advertisements', It didn't seem like it would have been the first time," Ray said. View the profiles of people named Hailey Bustos. Your daughter is just a little s*** that's going to rot in prison for setting Adam up to get robbed and murdered, the friend wrote in the comments section. Collins brother, 24-year-old Chad, was also shot five times but survived as he tried to help Jordan, according to police, the AJC reports. You can find out more and change our default settings with Cookies Settings. Police are unsure how the robbery escalated into a murder and said that Adam Hilarie was begging for his life, he was not putting up any kind of fight, and was telling them that he had a 5-year-old daughter," according to arrest reports. From top left: Andre Warner, Joshua Ellington, Hailey Bustos and Gary Gray have been arrested in connection with the murder of Adam Hilarie Online vixen Hailey Bustos, suckers, Adam Hilarie, into on-line dating set-up - the honey trap returns to date's home with three accomplices 'robs and kills him' Bustos, 18, accused of plotting with three men to rob and kill 27-year-old Adam . stars LaRoyce Hawkins and Patrick John Flueger tease Detective Hailey Upton's fate after season 9's major cliffhanger. Police killed a cars occupant after five officers fired 12 shots into vehicle they pulled over for a traffic stop in Farmington, Utah Chase Allan, 25, died sin, Alex Murdaugh shows no emotion as he is found GUILTY of murdering his wife Maggie, 52 and son Paul, 22, on June 7, 2021 Murdaugh, 54, who was facing between 30 years and life, Two California brothers convicted of beating groom to death with a baseball bat as he tried to protect his guests and bride, hours after he said his vows Rony Castaneda, Childs 1 am call leads to arrest of killer who shot dead childs teen sister, mom, 2 others dead in Canaveral Groves, Florida Responding officers found the bodies of, New Jersey woman fighting eviction blows herself up in house full of cats, during standoff with State Troopers State police had served the unidentified woman an eviction, Several dozen people are killed and at least 85 are injured in horrific head-on crash between two trains in Tempe, near Larissa, Greece on Tuesday night At least 43 people, ER nurse Rebecca Bliefnick, 42, suffered multiple gunshot wounds at her home in Quincy, Michigan, on February 23 Family members raised the alarm after she failed to pick up, Cops fired 12 shots at Utah law student, 25, killed sitting in his car during traffic stop Chase Allans family protest officers on the scene were immediately ordered to turn off bodycams, GUILTY! After their date, Bustos, Warner and other co-defendants went to the victim's apartment to rob him. Published on February 3, 2017. Detectives determined that Hilarie met a woman, later identified as Hailey Bustos, on an dating website, "Plenty of Fish." But early the next morning, she returned to Hilarie's apartment with three . Investigators are now looking to see if Hailey Bustos had been involved in a chain of honey trap robberies. Deputy Police Chief Ray offered a word of cautionabout dates with strangers found on websites. Bustos, accused of luring a man she met on the dating app Plenty of Fish, has pleaded guilty to conspiracy to commit armed robbery, robbery and theft. Detectives determined that Hilarie met a woman, later identified as Hailey Bustos, on an dating website, "Plenty of Fish." After going on a date with Bustos, police said the two briefly went back . formFactor: '001', The defense attorney also got Bustos to acknowledge her initial statements to Auburndale police investigators were not truthful. She oversees editorial content on Delish. Railroad shut down while police investigate reports of shots fired prior to injury accident.Railroad shut down while police investigate reports of shots fired prior to injury accident. "Justin is still very worried. Police said after the date Bustos met with three men to set up a robbery of Hilarie. Hilarie's mother is not buying that idea. A friend has launched a GoFundMe page to help with Hilaries funeral expenses. All three men - and Bustos - have been arrested. Learn More. According to an arrest report cited by the Orlando Sentinel, during the robbery Hilarie 'was begging for his life' and made no attempt to resist his assailants. Company. Detectives determined that Hilarie met a woman, later identified as Hailey Bustos, on an dating website, "Plenty of Fish." After going on a date with Bustos, police said the two briefly went back . 21:37 GMT 22 Aug 2016 2023 Court TV Media LLC, part of The E.W. Murdaugh is heckled as he leaves court, Ken Bruce finishes his 30-year tenure as host of BBC Radio 2, Ukrainian soldier takes out five tanks with Javelin missiles, Family of a 10-month-old baby filmed vaping open up, Missing hiker buried under snow forces arm out to wave to helicopter, Hershey's Canada releases HER for SHE bars featuring a trans activist, Moment teenager crashes into back of lorry after 100mph police race. You can donate here. She is a central figure in the case because she made first contact with Hilarie through a dating app called . They went back to his place, and she texted him later: I had a good time and would like to see you again. MORE: Hailey Bieber on her family's addiction struggles, supporting Justin in his sobriety "It's incredibly uncommon for a patient who is young and healthy to present a stroke, as it predominantly occurs in those over the age of 60," Sutton said. In cases like this, its easy for us to put ourselves in the shoes of the family, said a police spokesperson, as he detailed the arrest of four people in connection with the killing, including his most recent date, 18-year-old Hailey Bustos. Adam was a good man. Woman to Her Death with Promise of Baby Clothes, Mich. Man Allegedly Killed His Girlfriend and Shot Her Baby Because He Thought She Was Cheating on Him: Reports, Georgia Pastor Allegedly Stabbed to Death, Set on Fire by Former Inmate She Was Mentoring, Ind. The three men were identified as Andre Warner, 26; Gary Gray, 31, and Joshua Ellington, 26. You can read more from the Your Security Resource post by clicking here. Police say the teen then met up with three other men and hatched a plot to rob Hilarie. Twenty-seven-year-old Adam Hilarie met 18-year-old Hailey Bustos on the dating site PlentyOfFish.com. Andre Warner, Gary Gray, and Joshua Ellington came for televisions, an Xbox, and an iPhone, but they allegedly took Hilarie's life as well. , updated Adam Hilarie, a single father in Auburndale, Florida, made an online connection on the website PlentyOfFish with a woman named Hailey Bustos, and the two went out on a date Sunday night. Poole allegedly went with McGhee to meet with Jordan while Avery and Butler allegedly waited outside, according to CBS46, citing police. Bridges of Kentucky > Blog > Uncategorized > what happened to hailey bustos. "Seeing the pictures of these guys, in their faces, they looked like they didn't care at all, he said. Police believe there's a possibility that Bustos has been involved in similar crimes linked to online dating websites. Andre Warner in court on Tuesday, March 10, 2020. She is the partner and wife of Detective Jay Halstead. Cart; vintage milk bottle caps That was his world.". By Police later uncovered that Hilarie had met a woman by the name of Hailey Bustos on the popular dating site "Plenty of Fish." They went on to go on a date before going back to Hilarie's apartment, where Bustos was possibly casing the place for robbery. Most tragically though is how Hilarie is survived by Lajaya: "He really loved his daughter. After the men reportedly overpowered Hilarie and got into his apartment, Hilarie was begging for his life, he was not putting up any kind of fight, and was telling them that he had a 5-year-old daughter, arrest reports obtained by the Sentinel read. Hearst Magazine Media, Inc. All Rights Reserved. Three others Antonio Avery, Demarco Butler and Nashea Poole have also been arrested in the case, according to CBS46 and Fox5. }); She is portrayed by Tracy Spiridakos. The suspects, identified as Andre Warner and Joshua Ellington, both 26, and 31-year-old Gary Gray, allegedly stole valuables from Hilaries home, including jewelry and electronics. You can donate here. Our Spectrum News app is the most convenient way to get the stories that matter to you. Investigators are now looking to see if Hailey Bustos had been involved in other 'honey trap' robberies. Investigators got a break in the case after a witness reported seeing Hilarie with a young woman Thursday night and the police picked up Bustos in a separate burglary case . It is an interesting fact that several historical events happened simultaneously, which shocked the world. One of Dr. Phil's most asked about guests is back! When he responded that her trial testimony was based on the goodness of her heart, Bustos said it was. He is charged in the August 2016 slaying of Adam Hilarie. She has not entered a plea and no attorney is listed for her. "Hailey doesn't want anyone to worry about her, but it was a terrifying situation for both of them," a source explained. "It's her comfort with the way this went. Adam Hilarie met 18-year-old Hailey Bustos on the dating . They identified the three men as Andre Warner, Gary Gray and Joshua Ellington. Even if she gets out the streets will get justice so its better for her to stay in jail , if you want her alive., adidas Performance Mens Mana Bounce Running Shoe,Vista Grey/Black/Semi Solar Slime,8.5 M US. His loved ones said he was also a great father. One of the defendants woke her up a few hours later and asked Bustos to accompany them to Hilarie's apartment. While the AJC reports that a motive remains unclear in the shooting, investigators believe robbery may be behind it, according to CBS46. The trial is expected to go on for another two weeks. Published Mar 8, 2021. There was no . She saw him the next night, when on Friday she brought three men to rob Hilarie of TVs, an Xbox and an iPhone, and one of them shot him in the head, Deputy Chief Andy Ray said at a news conference. After the date, she returned to Belmont's apartment around midnight and told the people there including co-defendants Joshua Ellington, 29, of Lake Alfred and Gary Gray, 34, of Lakeland about some of the items in Hilarie's apartment, such as two TVs, an Xbox game system, jewelry, liquor and cash. She is due back in court on Oct. 7. His loved ones said he was also a great father. MORE. Alex Murdaugh: Inside the Mind of a Killer, Mallory Beach's Family Attorney Speaks to Court TV, Murdaugh Prosecutor and SC Attorney General Speak to Court TV, Michael Keetley's Retrial Set to Begin Monday, Alex Murdaugh's Defense Team Answers Questions, Chanley Painter Reports Outside Courthouse after Murdaugh Sentencing, Alex Murdaugh Says He's Innocent As He's Sentenced to Life in Prison, Prosecution Asks for Life Sentences for Alex Murdaugh, Juror Says Alex Murdaugh Never Showed Remorse. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed. location: 120, She is a central figure in the case because she made first contact with Hilarie through a dating app called PlentyofFish.com. Adam Hilarie's date was paid $50 to help rob him. Norgard focused on several inconsistencies among Bustos' previous statements and repeatedly suggested her trial testimony was an effort to get a better deal from the State Attorney's Office. text: 'Privacy settings', Somehow, it escalated. Kevin Bouffard can be reached at kevin.bouffard@theledger.com or at 863-802-7591. Prosecutors say the victim was set up to be robbed and ultimately killed after using a dating app. Police said that Bustos noticed items worth stealing in the apartment. Facebook gives people the power to. Deputy Auburndale Police Chief Andy Ray updates the media on the case Monday, August 22, 2016. Hailey Bustos, Andre Warner, Gary Gray, and Joshua Ellington (pictured above from left to right) have been arrested and charged with murder in the death of Adam Hilarie, Auburndale police announced Monday. privacySettings: { "Given the way it worked out, it seemed like that's what she was intending to do," said Auburndale Deputy Chief Andy Ray. The others face the same counts, but their first-degree murder charges carry a mandatory life sentence only if convicted. Cruz and his family are now planning a funeral while trying to come to terms with the loss. She and three men were later arrested and charged with first-degree murder . Ray believes Bustos may have been involved in similar robberies set up with dating websites. Chicago P.D. We are no longer accepting comments on this article. These Retro Fridges Are So! Ray said the robbery ended with Hilarie being fatally shot. "He brought the best out of everyone," Cruz continued. Bustos was staying with Belmont in her Auburndale apartment on Aug. 19, 2016, when she connected with Hilarie through the app and agreed on a date that evening. He faces charges of first-degree murder, robbery with a firearm, conspiracy to commit armed robbery and burglary of a dwelling with a weapon, according to 10th District Circuit Court in Bartow. Police in Florida have arrested four suspects in connection to a robbery and killing of a young father who was shot dead a day after he went out with a young woman he had met online. you want to continue watching? survivor season 7 cast where are they now; fn fal markings; massachusetts bowling hall of fame; darts players who have died; trident capital partners; similarities of indigenous media and information sources; 79 series coil conversion; leeton local environmental plan . Police later found many of the items in Belmont's apartment, and Bustos identified them as his property from police photos. I would hope that people can learn from this and just really take care of themselves and be really careful.". Hailey Bustos was allegedly paid to go on a date with Hilarie in order to set up a robbery that "escalated" into tragedy. Tess Koman covers breaking (food) news, opinion pieces, and features on larger happenings in the food world. Walz signs bill restoring voting rights for 55K felons, Convicted Salvation Army arsonist charged with trashing Caribou in Brooklyn Park, Minneapolis student pointed gun at another student, dean stepped between them: Charges, Man indicted in 2021 murder of St. __ATA.initDynamicSlot({ The victims brother, Angel Cruz, said that Adam brought out the good in everyone. Get hyperlocal forecasts, radar and weather alerts. 20. selena wants to create the narrative that the tiktok that hailey did with her friends was a shade for her, although the tiktok was long after what happened with sg, hailey clarified it but NOW selena commented on this on a tiktok, i swear her foryou is all about jailey Ray said Hilarie struggled with the suspects and then Andre Warner shot Hilarie in the head. Hilarie leaves behind his 5-year-old daughter, Lajaya, whom he had referred to in Facebook posts as his 'princess.'. Download our app, California Consumer Limit the Use of My Sensitive Personal Information, California Consumer Do Not Sell or Share My Personal Information, Offers limited or conflicting information. "You see picture after picture, just him and her. The Collins family could not be reached for comment. is now on season 9 and showing no signs of . His relatives have described him to PEOPLE as a devoted father with an ever-present smile. Our goal is to create a safe and engaging place for users to connect over interests and passions. Hailey Bustos is on Facebook. A young Florida father is dead and four suspects are in custody after, police allege, he was likely lured into a violent robbery by an 18-year-old woman he met on a popular dating site. AUBURNDALE (FOX 13) - Police charged four people with murder after one of them allegedly lured a 27-year-old man on a dating website before robbing and killing him. Selena Gomez has announced that she is taking a break from social media after an action-packed week on Instagram and TikTok. Bustos, Ellington and Gray were also charged with violation of probation. Andrew Warner, Gary Gray . Police say the teen then met up with three other men and hatched a plot to rob Hilarie. Adam Hilarie, was discovered dead inside his Auburndale apartment at around 6.45pm on Friday She and three men were later arrested and charged with first-degree murder in Hilaries death. "I just hate that my brother had to be the one to be an example. what happened to hailey bustos. The two emerged later and loaded up the car with Hilarie's property, she said. He also told them he had a child in an apparent bid to convince them to spare his life. hailey rose bustos in florida polk county 7/05/1998. "Once she got home, they talked together, they worked out the details, and then they went back and committed the robbery.". Promise. Get the best experience and stay connected to your community with our Spectrum News app. Norgard also attacked Bustos for remembering certain things from 2016, but couldn't recall other key details. Detective Hailey Upton-Halstead is a member of the CPD Intelligence Unit. Detectives determined that Hilarie met a woman, later identified as Hailey Bustos, on an dating website, "Plenty of Fish." After going on a date with Bustos, police said the two briefly went back . Aug. 18: Adam Hilarie & Hailey Bustos go on their first date. Man Charged with Murder After Allegedly Shooting the Mother of His Child Outside of Son's Daycare, Wis. Man Is Accused of Killing 6 People After Authorities Discover Selfie at Crime Scene, Ga. Man Allegedly Killed Daughter's Mother and Her Boyfriend During Custody Exchange: Reports, Ga. Man Allegedly Had Girlfriend Lure His Ex into a 'Fight' So That He Could Ambush and Kill Her. She is known as the young woman who claimed she was pregnant with baby Jesus, swore Eminem was her father and said she was a contestant on American Idol. Eric Dewayne Bustos passed away suddenly on October 22, 2022 at the age of 45. The three men were identified as Andre Warner, 26; Gary Gray, 31, and Joshua Ellington, 26. 2023 FOX Television Stations, Tom Sizemore, 'Saving Private Ryan' Actor, Dies at 61 after suffering brain aneurysm. Twenty-seven-year-old Adam Hilarie met 18-year-old Hailey Bustos on the dating site PlentyOfFish.com. According to the police report, Hilaire was fatally shot once in the head. Hilarie had met Hailey Rose Bustos on PlentyOfFish, which bills itself as the largest dating site in the world. "Given the way it worked out, it seemed like that's what she was intending to do," said Auburndale Deputy Chief Andy Ray. (DeKalb County police did not immediately respond to PEOPLEs request for comment.). Cops said 18-year-old Hailey Bustos, who was paid $50 to arrange the theft of Hilarie's TVs, Xbox and iPhone, returned hours later for the robbery with three friends. Your Privacy Choices: Opt Out of Sale/Targeted Ads. The defense attempted to imply that Warner might not be the realkiller and said that Bustos was finger-pointing to keep herself from a long sentence. An 18-year-old woman met a man online, went on a date with him, then brought her friends to his place where he was robbed and killed, Florida police said Monday, in an incident that has prompted authorities to warn about the dangers of online dating. After the men reportedly overpowered Hilarie and got into his apartment, "Hilarie was begging for his life, he was not putting up any kind of fight, and was telling them that he had a 5-year-old daughter," arrest reports obtained by the Sentinel read. __ATA.cmd.push(function() { The two went out for a date on Thursday evening, and that date included a visit to Hilarie's apartment. creative: { temple emanuel denver calendar. Now he's dead. He also told them he had a child in an apparent bid to convince them to spare his life. Hailey Bustos is an 18 year old resident of Auburndale, Florida. What happened? dave davies wife. Your California Privacy Rights / Privacy Policy. But early the next morning, she returned to Hilarie's apartment with three men, including warner, to rob him. Andre Warner is accused of being the trigger man. Whynter WC-241DS 24-Bottle Stainless Steel Dual-Zone Wine Refrigerator Get notified on your phone in the morning with the latest forecast and news to start your day. Even if she gets out the streets will get justice so it's better for her to stay in jail , if you want her alive.. Police in that case alleged that Hailey Bustos was paid $50 to arrange the Aug. 19 robbery of 27-year-old Adam Hilarie. reportAd: { Though they provided no further details, investigators also said Bustos had been involved in at least one other robbery similar to this one in the past. His body was found inside his apartment on Sunset Avenue on Friday evening. Auburndale father, 27, shot and killed inside apartment - Story | abcactionnews.com | Tampa Bay News, Weather, Sports, Things To Do | WFTS-TV, Florida father killed in online-dating setup - Orlando Sentinel. A 27-year-old Florida father was robbed and murdered Friday after going on a date with a woman he met online, the Orlando Sentinel reports. Follow. Her work has appeared on Cosmopolitan.com, Elle.com, and Esquire.com. Police in Florida have arrested four suspects in connection to a robbery and killing of a young father who was shot dead a day after he went out with an 18-year-old woman he had met online. Just one night after they went on their first date in Auburndale, Florida, police found Hilarie dead in his kitchen in what they now believe was an armed robbery that Bustos facilitated, the Orlando Sentinel reports. Auburndale Police Department Show More Show Less 2 of 3. A GoFundMe set up by a close friend of Hilarie is raising money for his daughter and funeral services, as Hilarie did not have life insurance. Almost immediately after he dropped her back home, she texted him, "I had a . | Privacy A friend has launched a GoFundMe page to help with Hilaries funeral expenses. Aug. 22: Police arrest Hailey Bustos, Andre Warner, Gary Gray and Joshua Ellington. After going on a date with Bustos, police said the two briefly went back to Hilarie's apartment. Unexpected: What Happened To Matthew Blevins After Season 3 Of TLC Show. "You see picture after picture, just him and her. The suspects stole multiple items, including electronics, from his apartment. Boeing employee bought lottery ticket because it was at $747M, a nod to the aircraft. He's all of our hero right now," said Angel Cruz, Hilarie's brother. Police believe there's a possibility that Bustos has been involved in similar crimes linked to online dating websites. id: 'atatags-1094607281-6403306bd9b09', It was not immediately clear if Avery, Butler or Poole have appeared in court, entered pleas or retained attorneys, according to court officials. What Will Alex Murdaugh's New Life Behind Bars Be Like? Detectives determined that Hilarie met a woman, later identified as Hailey Bustos, on an dating website, "Plenty of Fish."