are glocks safe to carry chambered are glocks safe to carry chambered

Not having a bullet in the chamber would make a discharge in the holster impossible. Too big, to heavy although I can cock the hammer on the draw with no problem (passive firing pin models). Ehall my pistolas are chambered with the safety engaged-at home. To sum up: there were a few objections to my original post that, on their face, had some truth to them. Cruiser ready generally refers to a gun that has a loaded magazine but an empty chamber. As for me on striker fired Im sure they are just as safe as any other design I just like to see whats going on, . Is it a lot of work to train to the level where you never get it wrong? If carry my Glock its in a solid Crossbreed holster with one in the chamber. You can lift and close the bolt to cock the striker quicker than doing all four motions. All of that seemed a bit verbose for a blog comment, though. I appendix carry my 42 chambered, the holster covers the trigger so I feel safe carrying this way, I been carrying this way for a while without issue. Its kind of unneeded though, because inertial firing pins can only build firing inertia on their own if the whole gun accelerates, and then stops suddenly. When the fight starts, ejecting a live round onto the ground, or hearing the click of a empty chamber, will just mess up your day, maybe your last day. But otherwise it still is a pretty good gunfight scene. I think they heard how bad its getting over here and want to provide a better place to be, so that TTAG will be left with nothing but trolls and snowflakes. I carry one in the chamber of my ruger P89 with 17 rounds in the magazine. It worked before. Maybe I counted wrong? Older single action revolvers or those still manufactured without a hammer block/transfer bar are theoretically more prone to discharge back in the day when you ride a horse as the drop from that position could allow the pistol to rotate muzzle up when it lands. His response could be ro shoot you with your gun. https://www.thetruthaboutguns.com/the-truth-about-6-5mm-ammo/ Please consider creating a . Big Bill: Yup. Many striker/plastic pistols, like the S&W Sygma, have actual DA triggers, that do not use glocks UN safe-action trigger scheme. Keep your finger off of it and your should be good to go. Of course, I do concede you point, it just that it brought Monty Python to mind and I improvised from there. There are some days (summer, mostly) when I carry the Walther PK380. We were assured that; were working on it. israeli carry is stupid. And my Glock 17. All the out of battery safeties do is, in one way or another, block the hammer from providing that energy to the pin until the gun is fully locked into battery. Considering how many types of expanding ammo my plethora of 1911s did not work very well with I gave up on them long ago. Thats a lot more true to life (in my admittedly inexperienced opinion) than most movies, especially westerns. The gunfight at the end was pretty good otherwise, but at one point Costner gets 16 shots out of his Colt SAA without reloading. This site is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to Amazon.com. Perfect analogy. I've never been to the range with you and I know . The end result is the same, but the means to that end are directly opposite in how they function. OthersI just didnt think about and for some pretty good reasons. If I was gona carry an empty gun Id carry a full sized 1911, that way if I had to throw it at somebody it would weigh enough to hurt when it him them. Wonder why guns are the most logical option? They DID make a variant with one (the Colt Cowboy) but they dont offer it anymore and the SAA is sold sans transfer bar. You could also chamber a snap cap, holster it, do your daily routine around the house and then check if trigger was pulled. (I dont think any of us are going to try to pocket carry a 1911 or a Glock 17.). To fire the pistol, the trigger safety and the trigger itself must be deliberately depressed at the same time. I never carried a gun before my G27. Glocks are awesome little handguns. It still works now, so long as the comment page is more than three years old. Does the gun have a firing block mechanism. When it didnt open the first time, your brain clicked again to make sure, often without one even knowing they did so. Various firearms but could go to dagger, spear, sword and buckler, longsword, or smallsword if for some reason one of those seemed like a good idea. Make that line above into: a solution in search of a problem. Ok, maybe youre taking off your holster and you drop the whole dang thing on the floor. whenever anyone posts on this page: If you liked this article, you might be interested in one I wrote all about Glocks Safe Action System. She had the edge, rock steady hands of a brain surgeon. Must not be working on it very hard. As I mentioned elsewhere here, the trigger pull and safety mechanism are irrelevant to the *proximate* cause of any Glock discharge Im aware of. silly? And in my opinion , and this would be scary, Id bet my draw and cock against the draw rack the slide anytime. This is the inherit design of a sticker fired pistol. Of course an ND is user error, but why is the gun designed to make that error likely? When I was a lot younger, I was riding horses with some friends. In some cases it's not legal. I have done special work to lighten my trigger and its still not very touchy. 2 you may forget to chamber De nada. Well, except for that ad hominem attack, anyway. There is no way to put a round in the chamber without leaving the striker cocked, and there is no safety. I asked administrator. Like a handgun, the defensive long gun should be secured in a safe or one of the wall-mounted quick-access locks. So in 2019, are you telling a revolver carrier to carry only 4 bullets instead of five?? Well, its nice to know Im negligible. On a range or match gun, OFC, my choice is different. They do have a half cock notch that you could use to carry on a loaded chamber, but theres a reason they say, Dont go off half-cocked. Descriptions: Glocks are safe to carry with a loaded chamber as long as they are carried in a decent holster that completely covers the trigger. Just bookmark the page you commented on, and then check back once in a while. All except for that one guy above who thinks muscle memory means hell never make a mistake, ever. Break into my house and well see how seriously you take a couple .44 mag slugs to the chest. Just the same as the guy thumbing the safety off, he will beat me. ADs by glockinstine operators usually are extracting their golden goose with or wit out a pocket holster, by placing their finger, as so many comments referred to above, on the trigger upon extraction. What an idiot libtard if you have a gun you get good at handling it stay with your BB gun, Mad says, What an idiot libtard if you have a gun you get good at handling it stay with your BB gun. Will again once they are old enough to figure out crapping ones pants is a bad idea. Glocks are designed with internal safety features to prevent accidental discharge. It is a DAO and . If you have your Glock properly holstered it cant go off, Those are what ifs what if you slip in the shower get hit in the crosswalk get rundown by a terrorist in a f150 train be vigilant and stay away from the end that has 6 letters. I am the same way, my kids randomly jump, hug or accidentally collide with me on a regular basis. So when does your Glock actually have a likely chance of discharging in those two most common klutz behaviors while handling a firearm? Are you my mother? Quick easy to access and small enough for the P365, a spare magazine, and a small 300 Lumen Tac Light. A 16 year old In drivers ed may not be very experienced nor skilled, but at least in my day, was paying more attention than a driver more familiar with driving. My AR is half loaded with the mag in but unchambered. Every time I drive. Glock 23 Handgun. The fact remains, we are always training. Since I do not carry(Los Angeles County), my handguns are ready very quickly. Appendix carry, when performed with the right holster and a trained hand, is perfectly safe, and that includes your Glock 19 handgun. It takes a dedicated squeeze of the finger. All that said, training, knowledge of your firearms design/function, and practice go a long way to make any firearm safe to carry with a round chambered though some designs are better for a particular purpose. We are compensated for referring traffic and business to Amazon and other companies linked to on this site. Those who defend not carrying a round in the chamber preach about it's safety. Carrying On An Empty Chamber. The Glock 43 is VERY close in size to the Glock 42, but chambered for that 9mm cartridge some people demand - or at least don't frown on like they do the .380ACP. Lol. Width: 1.18. And, it actually impeded officers ability to hit a target. you roll the dice. Risk vs benefit should ALWAYS be a part of this decision. All terrific replies. . It completely wraps the pistol in hard plastic so there is no chance of anything flexing into the trigger guard. One of them is as you describe (a 3-screw Single Six). Long story short, I let it be known that I thought carrying with an empty chamber is a mistake. Kathy Jackson suggests that doing this safely comes down to two things, equipment and habits. about carrying or keeping a gun with a round in the chamber. After all people driving cars kill more people than people holding firearms. Or tell them to carry only 5 bullets instead of six??. Guess what? Well saving room for some ice cream after dinner is a bit higher on my list than any damn LDL or HDL mumbo jumbo. In my 3-screw, yes. Let the flaming begin, No flame. Heres a news flash, ever since Adam and Eve ate the serpents apple were all fallible. Cycling against objects using your sight is slow and not easily done. If you want a common username better grab it quick though. From someone that ignorant, nothing he says or does would surprise me. Its a toughy. They didnt know. After all, this aint Dodge City and you aint Bill Hickok. Thats OK with me. Bottom line: For *any* firearm, you have to *put your finger (or some other object) INTO the trigger guard to fire the weapon.*. The list of pistols that have a drop safety to prevent the gun from going off unintentionally when impacted is quite long you need to look no further than any of the handguns allowed in the . For gun owners looking to maximize the life of their firearms, it's important to understand what type of ammunition is acceptable and safe to use in their guns. In that case, the argument that any gun is better than no gun might be correct but thats as far as it goes. There are tons of features that make it worth your consideration, starting with its trademark durability and flexibility. I have no issue using any of my Glocks as a SD gun, nor do I have any issue using any of my 1911s, any of my revolvers, or any of my other guns. Yes - I always carry with a round chambered. Recently retired the PPK in favor of a Sig P365. Absolutely YES!! When you thumb the hammer back for the first shot, it only rotates 1/12th or the way around instead of 1/6th. On one of those occurances, my snubbie bbl. But Knute is fine, and nobody else seems to want it. This is not remotely comparable to carrying a semiauto with an empty chamber, where the slide must be racked to make the gun ready to fire. Often, its holstering the gun into a holster that compromised by clothing. Someone who wants to spend a couple thou on a gun should be more than willing to put the energy into learning how to use it safely. A loaded GLOCK, some of the comments went, is susceptible to the dreaded GLOCK ND (negligent discharge). My wife carries her Beretta 92 loaded with the hammer down and the safety off so all she has to do is draw and fire; first shot DA and the rest SA. Therefore, its unsafe(ish) to carry or store with one in the chamber. I always wanted to see in a western someone who knew he was about to get into a gunfight slip that 6th round into his Colt SAA. 1 of 2 Go to page. Old school, extract, thumb, trigger finger, rinse n repeat often until autopilot takes over. I always wanted to see in a western someone who knew he was about to get into a gunfight slip that 6th round into his Colt SAA. The Glock 19 is one of the most popular models of Glock that is available on the market. Negligence or stupidity, flip the coin on word choice. He thinks. Empty chamber is one option, but there are others. In a SA revolver, the next round is instantly available anyway, whether fully loaded or one short, quicker out of the leather for the first, second, and third shot than any other existing action type. You'll want to train yourself one way or the other. These arent exactly the most concealable guns out there. Whats the controversy? Do not ever suggest they change a true classic. Glock developed their patented Safe Action System which will not allow the gun to be fired without a finger on the trigger and a dedicated trigger pull. Check out this post which is one of the most popular of all time. Perhaps why they werent interested in this modification, even though the investor designed it to be visually unobtrusive and to require minimal modifications to the original design. Even some shotguns will do that. Modern revolvers with some sort of disconnect can be carried full up. Maybe. I've carried both extensively. But now at my age I know me and I know my weapons and youll be gambling with your life if you engage me thinking you know whether there is one in the chamber. Both have pros and cons the secret is you must be well versed to bringing your gun up to the level of lethal quickly. Stop buying Glocks. Anyone who believes otherwise is delusional. Theyre both safe and useful within their own parameters, and people are free to choose the one they prefer. And that is the key to any methodology, simply having the proper training. Fat troll. As the saying goes, you do you. So F_____g what? Good luck!!!!! Actually, I only did that for about ten minutes before retreating to a men's room, unchambering the round, and putting the gun back in its holster with a full mag but empty chamber. A lot of guns, particularly the early revolvers, were considered too dangerous to carry with a loaded chamber because a sharp bump or drop could cause it to fire. For those afraid of carrying cocked and locked or striker-fired guns, the XD-E is a better choice than chamber-empty carry. Do u know what the 21 foot rule is? Usually for at least an hour or so. But the real benefit is in the noise. When something becomes familiar, inattention and negligence become more likely. The NYPD used this excuse several times to get out of a situation, basically saying These new-fangled Glocks just go off on their own. which for them is unwise because it feels utterly unsafe to do so ended up in the guys nostril, and he still didnt get quiet, until he heard the cocking of the hammer. You can also watch plenty of guys who have never once needed their guns in a confrontation, yet shot themselves because they kept one in the chamber. The hammer snagged on a branch, and he shot his horse (he was twisted by the tree). When carrying the gun in a holster, the grip safety will keep the gun from discharging, even if the . Learn your own weapon and try not to drop it, the last thing you do might be a good catch. You would probably be more likely to survive in a Banzai charge. All are coded alike, but each has a different weapon in condition 1 ready to go. Clearly not enough to train for scenarios where chambering a round can be life or death. P.T. For my "duty firearm", I carry a Glock Mod 22 Gen 4 (.40 S&W cal.). Even though they don't have . Again, though, training is the answer. You hit the nail on the head with "comfortable", but that is subjective. KAER adhere to the business philosophy of customer first, service first, quality first, and provide our customers with high-quality products and perfect service.. We are a professional manufacturer dedicated to the production of gun safes, safe box, pistol safe and other security products. Dont you dare break the three rules of safe gun handling. This has nothing to do with car=privilege firearm=right. The Springfield Armory XD-E is a new hammer-fired compact pistol. An unchambered gun is a dangerous, useless-to-you half measure. So Move. Not thinking human beings. So lets just say its a personal choice and your way isnt better than mine, but I will never accidently shoot my leg or foot. It will go off. What you are overlooking is the odds. An old retired civil servant who used to clean toilets in a federal building living off a small pension and social security. Ugggghhhhhh why are we still talking about this? *, Keep your damn finger out of the trigger guard until your sights are on a target you intend to shoot and you should be training to do that automatically *even* while under stress. I would consider the weapon fully loaded at this point. It was called Fractured Fairy Tales, The difference between you and me is I am real you live in a virtual reality world oh and btw dummy they dont call it Glock perfection for nothing, Your rants always remind me of that long ago cartoon show. Does the gun have a external safety, or is it internal. If the slide goes back far enough to be out of battery, then the gun will just fire out of battery. She now after many painful operations will be a partial cripple for the rest of her life. If anybody could advise me, I'd be grateful. I couldve even been Ken again, like I was here years ago. Granted, is loading a pistol, a shotgun or a rifle the most complicated thing in the world? Have you ever failed to yield the right of way when making a left turn? Glockster20. Some extras, just in case one breaks? Let the one with no traffic tickets throw the first stone. The gun itself Cannot be rendered safe without the chamber being empty. Carrying any weapon with nothing in the chamber is carrying an unloaded weapon. But it used to work fine, a year or so before that. What I want then is a big bang noise when I pull the trigger, and not much else. Does the Glock fire then? Lets talk about the internal safety features and the facts of why Glocks are great handguns.Jordy Bucks well worn Glock 20 is carried daily. I think five guns is the bare minimum, and thats how I always answer the one gun question. Just remember, about the only way you can deactivate the safety mechanism is with your finger. I know, its a big word, all scary long and has lots of syllables, but try it out. Barrel: 4.5. I got to 8 feet off the floor and a Series-70-style 1911 clone would not ignite the primer. The engineer who designed a take down system whereby the slide has to be forward and you have to pull the trigger must have on that day tripped out on LSD. When you purchase through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission, which supports our community. Hmaag [CC BY-SA 3.0], via Wikimedia CommonsTodays revolvers have a flat hammer. Come on, Gov, you know better than that. I dont understand why anyone who carries a modern firearm is afraid to carry a round in the chamber??? Carry chambered ever since. For all those terrified at Condition One semi-autos, a percentage carried hunting shotguns afield for upland game and waterfowl every one with the . Five years ago I reviewed the Glock 43, the second pistol in Glock's "Slimline" series of thin grip pistols. I would like to carry at the ready, but doing so really gives me the heebie-jeebies. If my chamber is empty, I obviously increase the chances that my gun wont be useful when needed, but I also reduce the chance of a ND caused by a minor in my care. So you are in reality arguing that if someone makes a *negligent mistake*, the Glock is more likely to discharge than another firearm. What Glock Is Most Used By Law Enforcement; Who Makes The Glock 22 carrying or keeping a gun with a round in the chamber, Standard Manufacturings New S333 Revolver Fires Two .22 WMR Rounds at a Time, District of Columbia AG Subpoenas NRA Foundation Financial Records, Gov. I would hope that all semi-auto handguns have some sort of striker/firing-pin block that absolutely prevents detonation from dropping the pistol. The G44 was thoroughly tested with a wide variety of ammunition to ensure maximum performance and . You always have time to do that. Some people were never meant to have a handgun I suppose. That carries over to shooting, believe it or not. The Israelis do it, and I do too. I am sure you will tell us that since you are a stable genius it will never happen to you. If waking up to a noise or shadow, I want the piece in my hand as simply and easily as possible, meaning it lays in the headboard. Same here. The pistol was designed to be carried with a round in the chamber with the safety on or off as your choice. If youre going to pocket carry, get a pocket holster. Jordan has taught marksmanship, woodsmanship, and self-defense classes. It has been many years since I saw that movie. How often are you a klutz when driving a car? I got two strikers, finally, couple years ago, a 9mm and a 40. It wont matter if the slide is in battery or not. We do all make mistakes. Run what you brung. Guns in my bigger safe are in condition 3 (AR rifles and defensive shotguns), except for my SAA revolvers are empty as I dont consider them as a defensive weapon (my hunting rifles and shotguns are empty too), mainly because both have 8 1/2 barrels and were used for silhouette shooting when I was younger. The Glock Gen 4 and Gen 5 models have become very popular with civilians and self-defense shooters alike. So you have no quibble with the line; If dropped, the hammer could contact the primer and therefore, fire., in relation to SA revolvers? PS: There was a 12 yo kid recently that subdued an attacker with a common socket wrench after Dad missed 39 times with a pistol. The Israelis do it because they had to come up with a training procedure that worked for all their soldiers, including those that dont know which is the end that goes bang. I can raise and lower the bolt slowly in complete silence. U.S. One was carrying a single action revolver without a transfer bar safety in a holster, and one under the hammer. sanctimonious what iffers so the theory still stands, if you dont want a negligent discharge, dont be negligent. In fact, when applying for a gun permit in Israel, self-defense is not an acceptable reason to get a gun. On the other hand, most other striker-fired pistols count on the recoil spring to cock the striker. It could easily tuck into a nightstand safe or tossed into a range bag. This debate has been going on for years.. which side are you on? Theres a problem with absolutism: youre proven wrong too easily. Sad, isnt it? The Israelis didn't invent the practice but it got the name from Israeli armed forces policy. I suggest a CZ 75 D PCR, in 9mm. However, there still isnt a compelling reason to carry a gun or keeping one for home defense that isnt loaded which cant be gotten around with a bit of training, a bit of brains, or a bit of extra gear. Glock 17. A revolver with an empty chamber under the hammer IS ready to fire. Not a bad plan. If you want a single action trigger pull, either carry a SAO autoloader in condition one, or choose a hammer fired model that one can manipulate its condition at will. Either you will practice with chambered, or chamber empty. My Taurus Millenium G2, basically a glock with a safety, same thing, actions are needed to make it fire. The Glock handgun is the favored pistol of law enforcement agencies worldwide. Ive said it once, Ill say it again. Its your right to self defense. Ammoland eh? Eventually, revolver designs changed. Theoretically, the slide safety could be accidentally disengaged in your holster rendering a cocked and locked 1911 significantly more susceptible to a ND when drawn given the user didnt know the safety was disengaged. I also felt the same way. I have no worries about the gun going off when holstering it or even worse going off by itself while in the holster as many Glocks have done when a fold of the holster got snagged inside the trigger guard. Glocks have only mode of carry once you chamber a round. The Glock 17 is a full-size pistol that is chambered in 9mm. But still a nice catch. I carry with one in the chamber but you choose not to. So the trigger pull is utterly irrelevant *if* you are paying attention to your firearm which you should be doing, again, with *any* firearm. . Congratulations. Hell, try it with a taser. In the absence of further information, which is never forthcoming, the logical conclusion is: They dont want to fix it. I could give you many other identical examples of Glocks going off while the owner wore them or handled them. The initial pull of this trigger performs generally the same function as the thumb safety of a 1911 or single action. One in the chamber is NOT ALWAYS the best option. I thought it was just the cops and regulars of the IDF. The first Glock safety that you will interact with is the trigger safety, which takes the form of a spring-loaded lever located in the center of the trigger. I have these 2 hidden and had mounted in my house. The 223/5.56 is the most common centerfire rifle cartridge in the US. Ive been known to knock over a glass of milk , spill my coffee down my chin , have people toot their horn at me from time to time , you get my point . and so as to keep continuity in their mindset they keep that same gun on the headboard at night with no round in the chamber so that there wont be any confusion I use either a DiSantis OWB when its jacket/coat weather or an Alien Gear 3.5 IWB when it Polo or T shirt weather. Vlad as always you are full of stupid.most semi auto today are Glock wannabes I have carried a Glock 21 for years I fast draw hip shoot and yes stupid Vlad I always carry with one in the chamber, Vlad as always you are full of stupid.most semi auto today are Glock wannabes I have carried a Glock 21 for years I fast draw hip shoot and yes stupid Vlad I always carry with one in the chamber, Your rants always remind me of that long ago cartoon show. Mr Hoober, If you werent too busy arrogantly doubling down, you might consider trying it some time instead of pretending you know everything but I suppose you are probably more interested in getting audience engagement than giving good advice. This subject is DOA just like the OP. If the trigger safety is not depressed, the trigger will not move rearwards and allow the pistol to fire. Kentucky CCDW Instructor. JavaScript is disabled. So old single actions have to be handled and loaded in a certain way to be carried safely. Also, had a KelTec with a pocket clip, no holster, ever, and a Glock 40 with a clip draw, and you just need the brains to have nothing else in your carry pocket, and you wont have an issue. You've only seen one page. 4) In such a rush and excitement even in a holster such as the case in Florida the police officer shot himself and the wall in a school and was clearly not in fear or stressed, so in all counts safety and training cause in the heat of the moment you may grab fast and shoot yourself. Second Amendment to the US Constitution, "Get yourself a Glock and lose that nickel plated sissy pistol." This is an older thread, you may not receive a response, and could be reviving an old thread. Big thing, its hammer fired and its also DA/SA, so I have no problem with chambering a round and lowering the hammer. Ok revolvers. It became the norm to carry with an empty chamber. Somewhat different than in rural MS tho, speaking as one who attended a full auto shoot at a local range about a month ago. Glock is a brand of polymer-framed, short recoil-operated, locked-breech semi-automatic pistols designed and produced by Austrian manufacturer Glock Ges.m.b.H.. Carry your GLOCK pistol chambered without worry, the same as every other modern striker fired pistol on the market. But in any case, the inertia must lie directly in line with the round, and then the round must stop suddenly, like when the muzzle hits the ground. If you can have a momentary lapse of judgement handling a half million ft/lbs you could certainly have one while handling 350. But my Glock has an empty chamber. (I don't think any of us are going to try to pocket carry a 1911 or a Glock 17.) I carry all my guns chambered. I notice that you had to go look it up though. As one gun writer said years ago, its amazing someone was not smart enough to hire a good gun savvy lawyer and sue Glock out of existence with all the accidents this pistol has caused. A S&W Model 329. Why would anyone want only one of something? Is A Glock Safe To Carry Chambered. I submit never. Ever have your computer go slow for a second, but then it opens two(or more) of whatever you clicked on? Hmm that give away means youre at least in your 60s bordering on senility. So, us non-glockentines keep a low pro on discussing polymers and plastics, but if I had to go to war tomorrow, you can it would be an all steel weapon. As stated above, Glocks are safe. They say tomato, I say Condition 1 Am I being silly? The others can safely be carried with a round under the hammer, with little to no chance of firing if the hammer should be hit or snagged. I find myself walking around with my hips thrust foward, flinching away from the gun. Note, the sentry safe does have a security vulerablity that can be mitigated by covering a hole with stainless steel tape. Ammoland was intelligent enough to allow only one person to use a name at a time. However, with an unchambered semi-auto, that may be a more credible concern. My Glock 23 is fully loaded, and no problems at all, even with the 3.5 connector in it that lightens the trigger pull a bit. An insignificant cretin crying for attention in a world that has left him far, far behind. While numbers vary, reacting to something - anything - takes a . There are 5 in the house right now; computer room (where I am) living room, bathroom floor (beside the throne) and both sides of the bed.